Thursday, November 5, 2009
Fez: An International City
After his their escape from Granada due to the Spanish Reconquest, Hasan and his family make their way to Fez (now called Fes, the third largest city in Morocco). Fez was once (around 1100s) one of the largest cities before Hasan's time, it was still a thriving center for trade and international commerce when Hasan's family settled there. Hasan's (Maalouf's) descriptions of the city add to this international image. Almost every Fezian's occupation is related to commerce in some way. Many women are involved in the marketplace, most of the men are merchants; for example, Hasan's father is called the "weigh master", Hasan's friend Harun is (or was, depending on how far in the book you are) involved in a trading guild. Later on, Hasan himself will leave behind his university studies and become a influential merchant, traveling to Timbuktu, Cairo, Constantinople, among other places.
Timbuktu, which was a very isolated city in the opinions of Europeans (this is why "Timbuktu" is sometimes used to describe someplace far away), was actually another center (albeit not central) city for international trade. Cairo and Constantinople were of course heavyweights in the global society as well (Constantinople was even one of the world's largest cities around 1600).
However, we get the picture that these cities, and the Islamic civilization in northern Africa in general, were in a period of decline. This might have been caused by the growing friction between Europe. Did these once-great Islamic cities--centers of international trade--turn against one-another and hasten defeat?
-Stefan Larson
Week 10
My one friend is Muslim and her family lives in the United States, but originally lived in Jordan. While, her family does not partake in many Muslim customs, they do not agree with her dating. They believe that the act of dating is useless, and while they have no set up an arranged marriage, I believe that they have Muslim boys in mind that they would like for her to marry. It's crazy to think how different certain ideals are all across the globe and how one thing that may seem perfectly normal to us is completely deviant to another culture.
week 10
I feel that the custom of arranged marriage is looked down upon in Western society because of our ideal of love from culture like Disney movies. In different societies, marriage is thought of differently so it unsurprising that there are different practices. I tutor a family of Somali refugees, and the eldest girl had an arranged marriage when she was 17. She invited me a few days before her wedding, and did so in a very nonchalant manner. I feel as if she did not mention her wedding to me earlier, because she worried that I would disapprove of an arranged marriage.
Most everyone can agree that slavery was a terrible institution as it dehumanized an entire people and forced them to leave their homes. However, it was necessary to dehumanize the people in order to justify enslaving them. Slavery was also justified by the Europeans through religion. They believed that it was their duty to convert the native "savages" to Christianity. I've often heard it mentioned that slavery was originally introduced in Africa by opposing African tribes, who would enslave their defeated enemy and later sold them to the Europeans. This seems to contradict what I was previously taught regarding African slaves and certainly puts a new perspective on slavery. However, it is not to say that because of this, slavery was not a great tragedy for humanity.
Africa was a part of the world system in a sense that it provided primarily the West with labor in the form of slavery. Africa was also highly exploited for natural resources like gold. West Africa was controlled by the Islamic Empire, and the time of Leo Africanus, Timbuktu was a center for trade and learning. Therefore, Africa is included within the world system, however, it is due to the outside influences of the Western and Islamic world.
Wednesday, November 4, 2009
Extra Credit Blog - Exponentialism
Leo Africanus- Blog 2
Did You Know??
But, is all this technology necessarily a good thing? Is it possible that we are accelerating at too rapid a pace and that one day, we will cross the invisible line? Because the facts are, the world's natural resources are rapidly dwindling, and as it is, we are running low on essential raw materials. With this exponentially increasing development of technology, is it possible that maybe these remaining materials will be used up at an ever-increasing rate as well, and soon, we will be left with nothing??
It's all a very scary through process, but its okay, because the world's supposed to end in 2012 anyway. Well, so the Mayans predicted. We'll see if they're right or not in due time. :)
Tuesday, November 3, 2009
Maalouf Blog 2
What I found interesting in this section was when the lions attacked the hut the group bedded down in for the night. I could picture myself on top of that roof. My situation would be somewhat different in that it would be my mother and sister inside, but I can still imagine the situation. The lions began scratching at the door, trying to get to the smell of the women and their dinner for the night. The two men watched, but that was all that could be done. Muhammad made a vow to travel to Taghya and place an offering upon the tomb of wali Bu ‘Lzza, who was a saint famous for miracles involving lions. The lions then after two hours of activity stopped and left the hut alone. If I were on that roof, before I heard the sound of a door breaking and jumped to save my family, I would have defiantly said a prayer to God that if he made this stop I would build a church in his honor. It was interesting to see the connections between cultures. I would have reacted almost the same as Muhammad in this situation.
My question is do you think Mariam is on the road to trouble? Is this foreshadowing to an event that Leo is going to have to take care of for her?
Sunday, November 1, 2009
Blog 7
Micro-history is one individual’s life to study history. In Leo Africanus we are looking at one man’s experiences while traveling. This is a very interesting approach, but his findings can only be generalized but so far. This prospective adds a unique point of view to history. It also brings the facts to life. For Micro-history to be reliable it has to be used in combination with something more objective. In this book he discusses the problems and struggles between Christians and Muslims. He talks about how Grenada has fallen to Christians and how people were discriminated against for what they believed in.
Part two:
I think that the idea of polygamy is very interesting to me. Poly gamy is something that is frowned upon in the United States and its interesting to see how something can be taboo in one culture and socially acceptable in another.
Part 3:
Why do you think polygamy is unacceptable in the United States and acceptable in other countries?
Saturday, October 31, 2009
Leo Arficanus Blog 1
This book is about Leo Arficanus, whose life we know very little about. The author creates this story and fills in the gaps of this mans life and history. The beginning of the book describes Leo Arficanus' early life when he is a boy living in Grenada. The story describes his father as having two wives. One of which is Leo's mother, and the other is a Christian slave. I have always found situations like this very interesting. Being acustomed to our society and culture, I can't imagine it being socially acceptable for a man to have multiple wives.
As the story continues, the man with two wives (Muhammad) gets both women pregnant at the same time, which does not go over well with either woman. The sense of competition is enhanced between the two wives. Interestingly enough, one of the women has a boy and other has a girl. The reader quickly see's the importance of a man having a son over a daughter in this culture as Muhammad pays little attention to his daughter and only focuses on the newborn son.
I'm interested in learning how the difference in religions between the two wives will be significant in the story. What will the juxtaposition of a Muslim mother and Christian mother mean for the development of the relationships?
-Justin Lovett
Friday, October 30, 2009
Leo Africanus
What I found interesting was about the structure of a family. How people in other countires will perform polygamy and think that it is acceptable. It's interesting to see how things have changed and also to compare their morals. Why are most polygamists male oriented and the women more of a possession to men. What has caused women to feel like they have no say or value?
Part 1 and Polygamy
I found it interesting that women of this time liked the idea of a polygamous relationship. Although it is looked down upon on today in a way that it is viewed as disgusting it was actually a smart, efficient way to live. This is my opinion. I do agree that it is out of the question in today's society but it did make sense to me of why they felt a polygamous relationship may be beneficial to everyone involved. My question is: What do you think the turning point of polygamy was that made people view it as something negative?
Historical Fiction
This week’s class discussion focused on “microhistory”, defined as looking at one individual’s life to study history. Our reading, Leo Africanus, is the This is nearly the opposite of what we have been doing until now. We are no longer looking at the world system as a whole, but one man’s experiences while traveling. The individual approach for studying history must be approached cautiously however, as one man’s experiences can only be generalized so far. A “great man’s” actions may affect thousands of people, or most of society, but he is still only one man. Using only a microhistory perspective can add rich detail to a historical study, but it must be used in combination with a more overarching survey.
The style of Leo Africanus particularly relates to historical perspective. The book is written as a fictional memoir of the life of a real man. Some of the events are very close to historical fact, while others are completely fabricated in order to tell a good story. And while the fabricated parts may be historically relevant, and based in fact, we must remember that not everything in the book actually happened. This book can help us put a more human face on the Middle Ages, but it is still a second hand, and fictionalized account.
I also reflected on how much liberty Maalouf can take while maintaining a historically accurate story. Everything in the book, all of the characters Leo Africanus encounters, and all of his experiences are realistic, but not all of them actually happened. The book may not be reliable as a textbook, but reading it is still worthwhile, yet I wonder, how much Maalouf can fabricate before the book is no longer worth considering a historical text and becomes a novel for enjoyment only.
Part one
One thing, which was brought up in class, is what is the difference from today and now? To think there ideas just 500 years ago are accepted in today’s standard is just ludicrous. I do not understand how someone could have multiply partners in marriage. Jealousy today would run wild; could you even image one woman with multiply male partners? No just ridiculous. To compare polygamy to being an only child is just wild. That is not even close to what we think or see today.
I wish he would have answered more questions about the slavery that was happening. I think this is something that is just not highlighted about in very many books and I would like to know more about it and how it really affected people around them.
Leo Africanus pt.1
Leo Africanus: Commentary 1
This week we began reading Leo Africanus by Amin Maalouf, which is a much different read from our past two books. Told in first person, we are giving fictional accounts of what life was like in Grenada during the 15th century. Hassan, our narrator, shares stories with us as they were told/passed down to him by his older family members. In this beginning section of the book, we read about hot topics in Grenada such as: women, alcohol, religion, and of course – war.
Because of its religious diversity (Christianity, Muslim and Judaism), Grenada seems almost as the perfect setting for this story. With such a widespread religious composition, I have to admit I was surprised when I read about Hassan’s father’s affair with a Christian slave girl, Warda. Why am I surprised? I guess it may be ignorant of me, but I would assume that in a city so religious-heavy – I wouldn’t expect one to have affairs, but I suppose I’m wrong. But I have to say – I was even more appalled to learn that his father’s wife, Salma, was also his cousin! Now I know – things of this nature were more common during this period of time, (and again this may be ignorant of me) but I think that is completely wrong, in more ways than one.
What I wanted to know more about would have to have been about the religious diversity. And maybe this will be covered later in the book, but what were the percentages of people in each religious category? I would like to know, how did they religiously interact with each other? Surely, some religions felt their religion was superior to others – how did this effect culture in Grenada during the 15th century?
Leo Africanus
Blog 7: Man of the World or Man Who has Just Scene it?
When Hasan speaks about himself, he never really identifies himself with one culture or nation. But he is constantly classifying others. The passage that stuck with me was:
“I, Hasan the son of Muhammad the weigh-master, I, Jean-Leon de Medici, circumcised at the hand of a barber and baptized at the hand of a pope, I am now called the African, but I am not from Africa, nor from Europe, nor from Arabia. I am also called the Granadan, the Fassi, the Zayyati, but I come from no country, from no city, no tribe. I am the son of the road, my county is the caravan, my life the most unexpected of voyages.”
His life truly is based on reactions to events. He is continuously changed by society rather than society changing for him. When I was googling him, I found numerous photos of him and was interested to see the different perspectives.


Third book reading
One reason I think religion is so much more valuable in America than in Europe is the history of each country. In Europe there has been a lot of unrest change in the government that America has never experienced. Communism, for example, is a government that took over many countries for as much as 50 years. Communism was extremely anti religion and after that rule people were lost in religion. There was not the history in the families to carry on the tradition so religion became of less importance. In America we have never been ruled by communism, nor had a president that was anything but Christian. People look up to the government no matter what is the rule. Most people in America are Christian, so that has never been questioned in such a degree as in Europe.
The nuclear family has always been an important value with Christian moral views, but in places like Middle East, people have different morals and values that do not include monogamy. In history having many women for many kids is considered normal in a lot of the Middle East. The practicality of having many women was to have children to work for you, mostly boys. These children were expected to work and they all had their place. In American history having children was also used for work, but that mentality has changed. In America today work and education is more important than the Middle East. Education and work beyond the family has not moved into a period of women being educated.
Leo Africanus Blog 1
Leo Africanus serves as a breath of fresh air in this class as well as my entire curriculum from dry textbooks to a more interesting literature portraying a culture in a more sympathetic, relatable way. I’m really excited about this narrative approach and the way that Maalouf sets his story to the background of historical events. It is a much more entertaining way to learn the history and culture.
Leo Africanus begins in the 15th century with Muslim Spain, a place I don’t know much about. The first story tells of a man, Hasan, living in Granada. His story gives us great insight into the society. His father had multiple wives, his mother and father were cousins, marriages were arranged at very early ages, there was great military power, the leaders (sultans) were uncaring and selfish, Granada was a trade center, and my favorite subject thus far, the Spanish Inquisition.
The Inquisition was led by Ferdinand and Isabella who were Christian Spaniards who demanded the ‘reconquest’ of Spain from the Muslim and Jewish hold that had occurred in their recent history. The Spanish Inquisition is notorious for its brutality. There were no limits to extermination, it was basically convert to Christianity or be expelled. It was amazing to have a firsthand account of these events which brought it to life as opposed to being a topic of interest in a history textbook. Hasan had to flee Granada and due to these traumatic events, he really wasn’t able to stay in one place for the rest of his life.
In regards to the Inquisition, I drew a lot of parallels from it to modern Europe. Today, there are many similar events and wannabe revolutions similar to the Inquisition in order to expel Muslims mostly from the fairly homogeneous Christian nations of Western Europe. Examples are the skinheads in England, Le Pen in France, and Geert Wilders in the Netherlands. But none of these figures have been able to start a major revolution or expulsion of these other races/religions. Do you think it’s possible for something similar to the Inquisition to happen today in one of these nations?
Dana Bodnar
Blog post 11/30/09
To retell history is a daunting task, but to combine it with narrative is almost impossible. It seems that Amin Maalouf has done the impossible with “Leo Africanus”, combining history and narrative, and doing so seamlessly and eloquently. He has taken a man whose life little is known about, and filled in every detail to create a story both compelling and fluid.
The book opens with the story of Africanus’ early life, as a youth in Grenada. It tells the tale of his family, his father and his two wives, one a Christian slave, and the other his mother, a Muslim woman, from his arranged marriage. There is a story of a rivalry and distress, not only among the two women, but within the two religions that inhabit the city. Both women become pregnant at the same time, and this enhances the rivalry of the women. However, they begin to bond over their shared abusive relationship with Muhammad (thank goodness for abuse!). When their children are born, Warla has a girl, and Muhammad is instantly disinterested. Salma has a boy, thus securing her place as the mother of Muhammad’s first son. The story then continues with a recounting of Salma’s childhood among the civil war in Grenada, and more events of Grenada.
What was most interesting was the situation in the family of issues brought on by polygamy. The fact that this was acceptable for a man in this society is very interesting just in how it is so different from our own society. What was it that made it okay for a woman to “imprisoned” as Salma is described in the book. She is simultaneously described as free. How would she actually feel about this?